Vatan Indian Restaurant (5)

With thoughts of the late great Anthony Bourdain, I set off to have dinner at Vatan, ready to experience a culinary adventure in my Murray Hill neighborhood. With an elephant patterned backpack slung over my shoulder worn especially to match the red blanketed trunk raised elephant adorning the restaurant’s front façade, I entered a long gastronomical rabbit hole-like vestibule and emerged in a large room decorated to resemble a village.

Vatan Indian Restaurant (12)

While listening to the pleasant background Indian music, I looked at the thatched covering over the booths, the huge god statue adorning the rear wall, the verdant fantasy tree planted between two booths, and the Indian woman painted on the table top.

Vatan Indian Restaurant (1)

Since the room was open in the middle instead of being packed with tables, the space was airy, communal, and inviting. I felt like I wasn’t on Third Avenue anymore.

Vatan Indian Restaurant (9)

Vatan is an all you can eat prix fixe vegetarian restaurant for $34 per person whose food hails from the Indian state of Gujurat.  The exotic experience began when the waitress brought water served in an interesting ornate copper pitcher. “There is nothing to order. Just eat and enjoy,” she said.

The appetizer course was contained on a partitioned silver tray. Another silver tray which held cute round food-filled silver bowls was an enticing presentational mode for the main course. After tasting what was on offer during these two courses, diners can ask for more of anything they would like.

Vatan Indian Restaurant (3)

I particularly enjoyed the condiments—chutney sauce, green and red sauce, pickled carrots, and roasted garlic—served with the appetizers. The entrée condiments—two kinds of rice and yogurt soup—were delicious. In fact, I could have made a meal out of the condiments alone. The chana masala was my favorite appetizer. I particularly enjoyed the chole entrée. I like beans!

After inquiring if I was comfortable with the food’s spice level, the waitress asked if I would like further helpings. Who could ask for anything more? Not me. The amount of food that was served was perfectly satisfying. Although delicious Indian food pouring down like mana from restaurant heaven was available, I had reached my satiation point. I did not, after all, want to become indistinguishable from the elephants which adorned my backpack and Vatan’s exterior. Hence, I only ate a small spoonful of the homemade Indian ice cream desert. You can visit here for information.

Vatan Indian Restaurant (2)

The numerous and diverse dishes deserve to be described in their entirety:


  • Chana Masala: Garbanzo beans with onions and coriander
  • Khaman: Puffed cream of wheat flour cakes
  • Muthia: Steamed flour with spinach
  • Mirchi Bhajia: Fried hot peppers with garam masala
  • Batatavada: Fried potato in a chickpea flour batter
  • Ragda Patis: Potato cutlet in a white bean sauce
  • Sev Puri: Potatoes, garbanzo beans, yogurt, and chutney filled in a crispy bread
  • Samosa: Pastries filled with spicy potatoes and green peas


  • Toor Dal: Boiled lentils cooked with Indian spices
  • Bhaji: Sauteed spinach and corn
  • Ful-Cobi: Cauliflower and greenpeas sautéed in a savory sauce
  • Batakanu Sak: Potatoes cooked in a mild red gravy
  • Chole: Chickpeas cooked with garam masala
  • Puri / Roti: Puffed whole wheat bread/whole wheat flatbread
  • Papadam: Thin lentil wafers

Vatan Indian Restaurant (1)

Eating at Vatan is like experiencing a culinary vacation from New York. Wonderful dinner over, I walked back through the vestibule rabbit hole and emerged into Third Avenue reality. As I passed by my usual Trader Joe’s, I decided to put off grocery shopping. Tomorrow is another normal food day.

Vatan Indian Restaurant (10)

– Marleen S. Barr

Vatan Indian Restaurant
409 Third Avenue
between 28th and 29th Street

Photos via Vatan Indian Restaurant